Can I use this toner every day?
Yes, most people can use it daily, even twice a day. Start once a day for a few days and see how your skin feels.
Is witch hazel drying?
It can be if you use the kind with alcohol. Look for alcohol-free witch hazel. Also, even alcohol-free witch hazel can bother some sensitive or rosacea-prone skin. If you are very dry or reactive, reduce it to 1 teaspoon or skip it and add a little extra rose water instead.
Do I have to add vitamin C powder?
Nope. The toner still feels bright and fresh without it. Also, a quick reality check: L-ascorbic acid is unstable in water and usually works best at a lower pH than most DIY mixes. In this recipe, it may do very little (or feel irritating) and it can oxidize faster. If you do try it, keep the amount tiny, patch test, and toss the batch if it starts turning yellow to brown or smells “off.”
Can I use apple cider vinegar instead of witch hazel?
I do not recommend it here. ACV is harder to balance safely for facial skin and can be irritating. Witch hazel is more predictable and gentle when alcohol-free.
Should I rinse it off?
No rinsing needed. Apply, let it absorb, then follow with moisturizer and SPF in the morning. If you feel stinging or heat that does not settle quickly, rinse it off and discontinue.
Who should skip this toner?
If you are in an eczema flare, dealing with very compromised or broken skin, have a known allergy to botanicals (tea, aloe, rose, witch hazel), or your skin is extremely reactive, this may not be the DIY for you. Avoid the eye area and do not use right after strong exfoliants or retinoids if your skin is feeling tender.
Can I double the batch?
You can, but I would not unless you plan to use it fast. Because this is a fresh, preservative-free DIY, smaller batches keep things cleaner and cut down on waste.