What is a Dark and Stormy made of?
At its simplest: dark rum, ginger beer, and lime. Some people skip lime, but I think the squeeze is non-negotiable. It keeps the drink from tasting like sweet soda with rum.
Is "Dark 'n Stormy" the same thing?
Fun cocktail trivia: Dark 'n Stormy is a trademarked name tied to Goslings Black Seal Rum (and it is traditionally paired with ginger beer). In real life, most of us use whatever dark rum we love and call it a Dark and Stormy. Same vibe, same delicious results, just a little less legal paperwork.
Is ginger ale the same as ginger beer?
Nope. Ginger ale is usually sweeter and much milder. Ginger beer has more ginger heat and bite, which is what gives this cocktail its backbone. If ginger ale is all you have, use it, but know it will drink noticeably sweeter and less spicy. Add extra lime and consider a dash of bitters if you keep them around.
Do I have to float the rum?
No. You can just pour rum in first and top with ginger beer. The float is mostly for looks and a little more rum aroma on the first sip. If you like the drama, float it. If you like simplicity, stir it.
What kind of rum should I use?
Use a dark rum you enjoy drinking. Aged dark rums bring vanilla and caramel notes. Blackstrap-style rums are deeper and more molasses-forward and can make the drink feel heavier. If you want a brighter, lighter version, use an amber rum.
How do I make it less sweet or less spicy?
Choose a drier ginger beer and add more lime for less sweet. For less spicy, pick a mild ginger beer, use more ice, and keep the rum at 1 1/2 ounces instead of 2.
Can I make a non-alcoholic version?
Absolutely. Use ginger beer and lime over ice. For extra complexity, add a splash of chilled black tea or a few dashes of aromatic bitters if you are okay with trace alcohol.
