What is a gimlet, exactly?
A gimlet is a classic cocktail built around gin and lime, sweetened just enough to make the lime pop instead of punch you in the face. Historically, many gimlets were made with lime cordial (like Rose’s), but at home, fresh lime juice plus simple syrup tastes brighter and cleaner.
Can I use bottled lime juice?
You can, but it will taste more dull and sometimes a little metallic. If you are already shaking a two-minute cocktail, it is worth squeezing a lime. One medium lime usually gives about 1 ounce of juice.
What is the best gin for a gimlet?
London Dry styles are the most classic, but almost any gin works. If your gin is very floral, you might prefer the gimlet slightly drier. If it is super piney, a touch more syrup can round it out.
Is a gimlet served up or on the rocks?
Both are common. I like it served up in a chilled coupe for that crisp, clean vibe. If you want it to stay colder longer, serve it over fresh ice in a rocks glass.
How do I make it less sweet or more sweet?
Start with the base ratio in the recipe, then adjust by 1 teaspoon of syrup at a time. Sweetness is personal, and limes vary a lot.
Can I use lime cordial instead of fresh lime and syrup?
Yes. If you are using lime cordial, start with 1/2 to 3/4 oz cordial with 2 oz gin, shake with ice, then taste and adjust. Cordials vary wildly in sweetness and tartness, so treat the first one like a draft.
Can I make a gimlet without alcohol?
Yes. Swap the gin for a nonalcoholic gin alternative. If you want extra bite, use nonalcoholic bitters, or skip bitters entirely for fully alcohol-free. Keep the lime and syrup, shake with ice, then strain.