Common Questions
Do I drain the canned peaches?
Usually, yes. For the most reliable texture, drain the peaches, then add back 1/3 to 1/2 cup of the syrup or juice. If your peaches are packed in heavy syrup, start with 1/3 cup. If they are packed in juice, 1/2 cup is usually perfect. The goal is saucy, not soupy.
Quick note: Peaches in syrup taste a little richer. Peaches in juice work great too. If you are using no sugar added peaches, you may want the optional brown sugar so it still tastes like dessert.
Why is my cake mix still powdery on top?
Dump cakes can do that if the butter does not hit all the dry mix. Two easy fixes: slice the butter thin and cover the surface evenly, and if you see dry patches halfway through baking, drizzle 1 to 2 tablespoons of melted butter over the spots.
Can I use fresh or frozen peaches?
Yes. For fresh peaches, peel if you want, then slice about 5 to 6 cups and toss with 1/2 cup sugar plus 1 tablespoon cornstarch. For frozen, thaw and drain well first, then use the same approach. If your peaches are especially juicy after thawing, add an extra 1 to 2 teaspoons cornstarch to help it thicken.
What cake mix works best?
Yellow cake mix is the classic. Spice cake mix tastes like fall in a pan. White cake mix keeps it lighter. Butter pecan is dangerously good if you can find it.
Can I make it ahead?
You can bake it earlier in the day and rewarm before serving. If you assemble and refrigerate unbaked, the cake mix can hydrate weirdly, so I prefer baking it fresh when possible.
Can I use peach pie filling?
You can. Use 2 cans (21 ounces each) peach pie filling and skip adding the reserved syrup/juice. Pie filling is already thickened and sweetened, so it does not need the extra liquid.
Do I have to add nuts?
Nope. Leave them out if you prefer, or if you are serving someone with a nut allergy. The cake still gets crisp and buttery without them.