What is cachaça and can I substitute it?
Cachaça is a Brazilian spirit distilled from fresh sugarcane juice. It tastes grassy, slightly funky, and bright. If you cannot find it, use a light rum for a close cousin (technically that turns your drink into something more like a “caipirissima”). Still delicious, just different.
Should I use simple syrup instead of sugar?
You can, but classic caipirinhas use granulated sugar. The crystals help abrade the lime as you muddle, pulling more aroma from the peel. If you use simple syrup, start with 1/2 to 3/4 ounce and adjust to taste.
Why does my caipirinha taste bitter?
Usually it is from over-muddling the lime peel or using too much white pith. Muddle firmly but briefly, and cut the lime to avoid lots of pith-heavy pieces. Also, make sure you are not using old, dry limes.
Crushed ice or cubes?
Crushed ice is the move. It chills fast and gives that signature slushy, beach-bar texture. If you only have cubes, give them a quick smash in a bag with a rolling pin.
How do I make a batch for a party?
You can muddle lime and sugar in a pitcher, add cachaça, and chill. Serve over fresh crushed ice in glasses. Expect about 2 limes and 4 teaspoons sugar per 2 drinks, then adjust to your crowd’s sweet tooth.
Quick batching tip: muddle gently and briefly to avoid bitterness, and taste as you go. For the very best flavor, pre-cut your limes and muddle per glass, then add the pre-measured cachaça.