Mom's Best Recipes
Recipe

Smoky & Spicy Homemade Paella

A weeknight-friendly paella-style rice with smoky paprika, juicy chicken, quick-seared shrimp, and crisp socarrat on the bottom.

Author By Matt Campbell
4.8
A wide paella pan filled with smoky saffron rice, browned chicken pieces, shrimp, roasted red peppers, and lemon wedges on a wooden table

Paella is one of those dishes that looks like a special-occasion flex, but the core idea is actually very home-cook friendly: build a bold base, let the rice soak it all up, then stop touching it and let the bottom get crispy. That last part is the magic.

This homemade paella recipe leans smoky and spicy with smoked paprika, a little cayenne, and a saffron optional situation that I will never shame you for skipping. We do chicken for depth, shrimp for the "okay wow" bite, and a bright lemon finish so the whole pan tastes alive, not heavy.

A close-up of a spoon scooping saucy smoky rice with a piece of chicken and a shrimp from a paella pan

Why It Works

  • Big flavor fast: smoked paprika, garlic, and a concentrated tomato base make the rice taste like it cooked all day.
  • Reliable texture: a controlled simmer cooks the rice evenly, while a final heat boost gives you that coveted socarrat (crispy bottom).
  • Spice you can control: you choose mild, medium, or "I can feel my eyebrows sweating."
  • One-pan energy: minimal cleanup, maximum dramatic entrance to the table.

Pairs Well With

Storage Tips

Paella leftovers are still a win, especially if you treat the rice gently.

Refrigerate

  • Cool quickly, then store in an airtight container for up to 3 days.
  • If shrimp is in the mix, I try to eat it within 2 days for best texture.
  • If you are planning for leftovers, you can also pull the shrimp off once it is just cooked, then tuck it back on when reheating to avoid overcooking.

Reheat

  • Skillet method (best): add a splash of broth or water, cover, and warm over medium-low until hot. Uncover for the last minute to re-crisp a little.
  • Microwave method: sprinkle with water, cover loosely, and heat in 45-second bursts, stirring once.

Freeze

  • You can freeze it for up to 2 months, but shrimp can turn a bit bouncy. If you know you want freezer portions, freeze the rice and chicken, then cook fresh shrimp later.

Common Questions

Do I need a paella pan?

No. A 12 to 14-inch skillet works great, ideally stainless steel or cast iron. Nonstick is not my favorite here because socarrat is harder to develop.

Pan size matters: try to keep the rice in an even layer, roughly 1/2 to 3/4-inch deep. If your pan is smaller and the layer is thicker, expect a little more cook time and you may need extra broth.

What rice is best for paella?

Traditional options are bomba or calasparra because they absorb liquid without turning mushy. If you cannot find those, Valencia rice is a great option.

If you are in a pinch, medium-grain rice like arborio will work, but expect a slightly creamier texture (more risotto-adjacent). Avoid long-grain rice, which cooks up too separate for this style.

Can I make it less spicy?

Yep. Skip the cayenne, use a mild sausage, and keep the smoked paprika but choose sweet smoked paprika instead of hot.

Why is my rice crunchy?

Most often it needs more liquid and a little more time. Pan size, burner strength, and how hard your simmer runs can change evaporation a lot. Add a splash of warm broth, cover, and simmer gently for 5 to 8 minutes.

Other common culprits: the rice layer was too thick, or the heat was high enough to evaporate liquid too fast before the grains finished cooking.

How do I know when socarrat is happening without burning it?

You will smell a toasty, nutty aroma and hear more crackling as the liquid finishes. Give the pan a short blast over medium-high at the end, then stop.

If you want extra confirmation, slide a spoon under the rice near the edge and peek. You want deep golden and crisp, not black. If it smells sharp or acrid, you went too far.

What kind of chorizo should I use?

Use Spanish-style cured chorizo (firm, sliceable) or a smoked sausage like andouille. Avoid raw Mexican-style chorizo here unless you plan to fully cook and crumble it first, because it behaves like fresh sausage.

The first time I tried to make paella at home, I did what every slightly overconfident cook does: I stirred it like risotto. The rice got creamy, the bottom stayed sad, and I learned a lesson that still applies to a lot of cooking. Sometimes the best move is to stop "helping." Now I treat paella like a team sport. Build the base, give the rice what it needs, then trust the pan to do its thing. The reward is that crispy little layer on the bottom that makes everyone suddenly quiet at the table.