What cut of steak is best for Steak Diane?
Classic Steak Diane is often made with filet mignon medallions because they cook quickly and stay tender. You can also use top sirloin (more affordable) or strip steak cut into portions. Aim for pieces about 1 to 1 1/2 inches thick so you can get a good sear without overcooking.
If using strip steak: cut into 4 portions and, if needed, lightly pound or trim so the pieces are an even thickness. Cook to temperature, not the clock.
Do I have to flambé the brandy?
Nope. Flambé looks cool and can add a little extra aroma. It also burns off some alcohol quickly, but it does not magically erase it all. The sauce is still delicious if you simply simmer the brandy for 30 to 60 seconds.
What can I use instead of brandy or cognac?
Brandy or cognac is the classic move. If you are out, use dry sherry or marsala for a similar warm depth. In a pinch, you can use beef broth with a tiny splash of apple cider vinegar for brightness, but it will taste less traditional.
How do I keep the steak from overcooking while I make the sauce?
Two things: rest it off the heat (on a plate, tented loosely with foil) and make the sauce in the same pan quickly. You will add the steak back for only 30 seconds to 1 minute at the end, just to coat and warm.
My sauce broke or looks greasy. Can I fix it?
Yes. Take the pan off heat and whisk in 1 to 2 tablespoons cold butter to bring it back together. If it is too thick, add a splash of broth. If it is too thin, simmer for another minute or two before finishing with butter or cream.
What internal temp should I aim for?
Think in terms of pull temperature (what you hit in the pan) plus carryover while resting. Pull at about 120 to 125 F for medium-rare, then rest to roughly 130 to 135 F. Pull at 130 F for medium, rest to around 135 to 140 F. If you like rare, pull around 115 F. For medium-well, pull around 140 to 145 F and know the medallions will tighten up a bit.