Common Questions
Why do my cookies spread too much?
Most common culprits are butter that is too soft, warm dough, or a hot baking sheet. Chill the dough for 20 to 30 minutes, and always scoop onto a cool pan. If your kitchen is warm, chilling is not optional, it is survival. (Also, it helps the cookies hold their shape.)
Can I make these without a mixer?
Yes. Use a wooden spoon or sturdy spatula to cream the butter and sugars (a whisk can be awkward unless your butter is very soft). Then stir in the eggs and vanilla, and fold in the dry ingredients. The cookies may be a touch more rustic, but the flavor stays excellent.
What makes these taste “rich and savory”?
It is the combo of brown sugar (caramel depth), vanilla, and enough salt to keep the sweetness from going flat. That extra salt can make the chocolate taste even more chocolatey. Optional flaky salt on top really makes the chocolate pop.
Should I chill the dough?
You do not have to, but I recommend it. Even 20 minutes helps control spread and improves flavor. If you can chill for overnight, you will get deeper caramel notes.
Can I reduce the sugar?
You can reduce each sugar by 2 tablespoons, but know it will affect texture. Less sugar usually means less spread and a more cake-like cookie. If you want less sweetness without messing with structure, use bittersweet chocolate and keep the sugar as written.
How do I get perfect round cookies?
Right when they come out of the oven, place a larger round glass or cookie cutter around a cookie and gently swirl to “scoot” the edges into a circle.