Mom's Best Recipes
Recipe

Ultimate Ricotta Recipe

Creamy, rich, and unapologetically savory ricotta you can make at home with simple ingredients and big flavor.

Author By Matt Campbell
4.8
Jump to Recipe

Ricotta has a reputation for being “that soft white cheese” you buy once for lasagna and then forget in the back of the fridge. Not today. This is the ultimate ricotta situation: plush, warm, and savory, with enough seasoning to make you swipe the spoon through it like it owes you money.

We are making a homemade ricotta that feels a little fancy but is actually very low drama. It is just milk, cream, an acid, and salt. Then we take it from mild to memorable with olive oil, lemon zest, herbs, and pepper. Use it on toast, fold it into pasta, dollop it onto soup, or eat it straight from the bowl while pretending you are “tasting for quality.”

Why It Works

  • Silky texture with real body: A splash of cream and gentle heat give you ricotta that is creamy, not grainy.
  • Reliable curds every time: Warm the dairy to the right temp, then let the acid do its job without over-stirring.
  • Flavor that shows up: Salt in the curds, then a savory finish of olive oil, lemon zest, herbs, and black pepper.
  • Flexible end game: Drain longer for a thicker ricotta (great for pasta and baking) or shorter for spoonable, dip-worthy softness.

Pairs Well With

  • Toasted sourdough with olive oil and flaky salt

  • Roasted tomatoes and garlicky pan juices

  • Lemony pasta with pepper and greens

  • Warm marinara for dipping and dolloping

Storage Tips

Fridge: Store ricotta in an airtight container for up to 3 to 4 days. Cool it quickly, refrigerate promptly, and use clean utensils. Press a piece of parchment or plastic wrap directly on the surface to prevent drying.

Drain control: If it weeps a little liquid (totally normal), just stir it back in for a looser texture or pour it off for thicker ricotta.

Freezer: You can freeze ricotta for up to 2 months, but the texture becomes more crumbly after thawing. Best use is in baked pasta, casseroles, pancakes, or stuffed shells, not as a fresh dip.

Reheat: If using in something warm, add it at the end over low heat. Ricotta can tighten if it gets blasted with high heat.

Common Questions

What is the best milk for homemade ricotta?

Use regular pasteurized whole milk for the best texture and yield. Avoid ultra-pasteurized (UHT) milk if you can. It can technically curdle with acid, but it often gives you smaller curds, a grainier texture, or a disappointing yield.

Can I make it without heavy cream?

Yes. You will still get ricotta with whole milk alone, but the cream makes it richer and silkier. If skipping, consider adding an extra tablespoon of olive oil at the end for that lush mouthfeel.

Vinegar or lemon juice, which is better?

Both work. Lemon juice gives a brighter, cleaner flavor. White vinegar is very neutral and super consistent. Lemon acidity can vary, so vinegar is the more reliable choice if your lemons are old or mild.

Why didn’t my milk curdle?

Usually one of four things: the dairy was not hot enough, the acid amount was too low, you stirred too aggressively, or your milk was ultra-pasteurized. Make sure you hit around 185 to 195°F, add the full acid amount, and then leave it alone to curdle. If curds still do not form after 2 to 3 minutes, add 1 teaspoon more acid at a time, gently, and wait another minute.

How do I make it thicker (basket-style)?

Drain longer. Start checking at 10 minutes, then keep going until it matches your goal. For very thick ricotta, drain 30 to 45 minutes and chill before using. Note: traditional “basket ricotta” is often whey-based ricotta, but this method gets you that same thick, spreadable vibe.

I started making ricotta at home because I kept buying tubs for one recipe and then side-eyeing the leftovers like, “Now what?” The first time I made it myself, I realized the real trick is not magic. It is temperature, patience, and salt. Suddenly ricotta stopped being a background character and became the thing people hovered around with crackers.

Now it is my go-to when I want something cozy but not heavy. I can get curds draining while pasta water boils, and five minutes later I am eating toast with warm ricotta, olive oil, and pepper like I planned my life better than I did.