Common Questions
How long should I soak a cedar plank?
Many cooks soak for at least 1 hour, and up to 4 hours. It can help a bit (especially with thinner planks) by slowing down scorching and encouraging smoldering. If you are short on time, 30 minutes is better than nothing, but expect more charring.
Should I soak the plank in water, salt water, or something else?
Plain water is perfect. Some people use wine, beer, or citrus water, but the smoke flavor mostly comes from the cedar itself. If you want to play, add a few lemon slices to the soaking water for vibes, not magic.
What internal temperature should salmon be?
For food safety, the FDA guideline is 145°F at the thickest part. For a juicier, slightly translucent center, many home cooks pull earlier and let carryover finish the job. A handy map: 125°F is usually medium-rare, 130°F medium, 135°F medium-well (depending on thickness and rest). If you are cooking for kids, pregnancy, elderly, or anyone immunocompromised, stick with 145°F.
How do I know it is done without a thermometer?
Look for salmon that turns opaque on the outside and separates into clean flakes when you press it with a fork, while still looking moist (not chalky). A thermometer is still the easiest way to stay relaxed.
Can I do cedar plank salmon in the oven?
Yes. You will get less smoke than a grill, but the plank still cushions the heat and adds aroma. Use a hot oven, place the plank on a sturdy rimmed baking sheet, and make sure you have good ventilation. Also check your plank packaging for any oven-specific guidance.
Is it safe if the plank catches fire?
A little flame at the edges can happen, especially on a hot grill. Keep a spray bottle of water nearby and move the plank to a cooler, more indirect zone if needed. You want smoldering, not a bonfire.
Do I have to discard the plank after cooking?
Best practice is to treat it as a one-time use item. If you do reuse, only do it if it is not heavily charred, still structurally sound, and you can scrub it well (no soap) and dry it completely. When in doubt, toss it.