What exactly are petit fours?
Classic petit fours are small bite-sized cakes, usually layered with jam or buttercream, then coated in a smooth poured fondant style icing. They are meant to be elegant, small, and easy to eat in two or three bites.
Do I have to use poured fondant?
No. Traditional poured fondant is its own thing, but a thick powdered sugar glaze gets you very close in look and feel, with ingredients you can grab anywhere. It sets, it shines, and it tastes like vanilla frosting’s glossy cousin.
My 9x13 cake seems thin. Is that okay?
Yes. This recipe is designed as a thin sheet cake on purpose so you can stack two rectangles with jam in between and get that tidy petit four look without trying to split a thicker cake.
If you want a thicker cake layer, you can bake the batter in an 8x8 or 9x9 pan instead. Bake time will be longer, so use the doneness cues (springy center and a clean toothpick).
Why did my glaze turn see-through or soak in?
That usually means it was too warm or too thin, or the cake was not chilled. Chill the cut cake squares well and make the glaze thick enough that it ribbons off a spoon and holds its shape for a second before disappearing.
How do you get neat squares?
Chill the cake, use a long serrated knife, and wipe the blade between cuts. Also, trim the outer edges first. They are delicious, but they are not your best “presentation” pieces.
What is the smoothest way to glaze petit fours?
You have two good options:
- Spoon-and-sweep: Spoon glaze over the top and use the spoon to nudge it to the edges. Great if you are working slowly and do not want crumbs in the bowl.
- Dip method: Hold a chilled square and dip the top straight down into the glaze, lift, let excess drip, then set on the rack. This can give a super smooth top quickly.
If the glaze starts setting in the bowl, warm it for 5 to 10 seconds in the microwave and whisk, or whisk in 1 teaspoon milk at a time to loosen.
Can I make these for a party the day before?
Yes. In fact, they are easier that way. Bake and chill the cake the day before, then cut, fill, and glaze the next day. Once glazed, give them at least 1 hour to set before stacking or transporting.