Common Questions
Why did my ornaments puff up?
Usually it is a combo of too high oven temp or too thick dough. Keep the oven low (250°F), roll to about 1/4-inch, and poke tiny bubbles with a toothpick if you see them forming early in the bake.
Why are my ornaments cracking?
Cracking happens when the outside dries faster than the inside. Bake low and slow, flip halfway, and do not rush the cool-down. Also, keep the thickness even so skinny spots do not dry out first.
Do I have to bake them, or can they air dry?
You can air dry, but it takes longer (often 2 to 5 days, and up to a week in humid climates) and they can warp. Baking is faster and more consistent.
How do I keep them from warping or curling?
Roll evenly, bake on parchment, and flip halfway. If your oven has hot spots, rotate the pan. Also avoid very wet decorations (like heavy glue) on only one side before the ornament is fully dry.
Can I use these for handprints?
Yes. For handprints, I roll slightly thicker, closer to 3/8-inch, then extend bake time. Press firmly, smooth rough edges with a damp fingertip, and make the hanging hole a bit larger since thicker dough can shrink slightly.
How do I make them last for years?
Let them dry completely, then seal them well. A couple thin coats of water-based polyurethane, Mod Podge, or a clear acrylic sealer helps protect from humidity. Seal both sides and the edges, and store dry with padding.
Are salt dough ornaments safe for pets to eat?
No. They are very salty and not a pet treat. Keep ornaments, scraps, and especially salty dust away from pets.
Can I color the dough?
Yes. You can knead in a drop or two of food coloring, or add spices like cinnamon for a warmer color. Just note that spices can darken more as they bake. And even if it looks like cookie dough, it is not edible.