Are shishito peppers spicy?
Usually they are mild and slightly sweet. But every so often you will get a spicy one. It is normal and part of the fun.
Do I need to poke holes in shishito peppers before cooking?
No. Shishitos blister just fine without poking. They can occasionally spit a little steam or oil when they hit a screaming hot pan, so stand back for the first few seconds and use a splatter screen if you want. Keeping them whole helps them stay juicy inside while the skin chars.
Why are my shishitos not blistering?
Your pan is not hot enough, the peppers are wet, or the pan is crowded. Dry them well, preheat the skillet until it is properly hot, and cook in a single layer.
Can I make these without soy sauce?
Yes. Use tamari, coconut aminos, or just finish with lemon and flaky salt. A splash of rice vinegar also works for brightness.
What dipping sauce goes with blistered shishitos?
They are great with kewpie mayo, garlic aioli, ranch, or a quick yogurt dip with lemon and grated garlic.
Can you eat the stems?
Yes, they are edible, but most people leave them on as a built-in handle and just nibble around them.