Common Questions
What makes this tuna melt sweet and spicy?
The combo of honey and sriracha. Honey gives a sticky sweetness that rounds out the heat, and sriracha adds chili punch plus a little garlic tang.
Can I use canned tuna in oil instead of water?
Yes. Just drain it well. Tuna in oil tastes richer, so you may want an extra squeeze of lemon or a little more pickle to keep it bright.
What kind of tuna is best?
Chunk light is softer and mixes up super creamy. Solid albacore stays meatier and a little firmer. Both work, so use what you like. Either way, drain it well and if it is still wet, press it in the strainer (or the can) with the back of a spoon to squeeze out extra liquid.
What bread works best?
Sourdough is my top pick for crunch and tang, but white sandwich bread, brioche, or a sturdy whole wheat all work. The key is bread that can handle a skillet without going floppy.
What cheese should I use?
Sharp cheddar brings the best bite, but pepper jack is great if you want more heat, and provolone is smooth and melty. Use what you have, just pick something that melts well.
How do I keep the tuna melt from getting soggy?
- Drain the tuna very well. Press it a bit if you need to.
- Toast the inside of the bread lightly before assembling if your bread is extra soft.
- Cook low and slow enough to melt the cheese without steaming the sandwich.
Can I make it less spicy for kids?
Absolutely. For a very mild version, start with 1 teaspoon sriracha (instead of 1 tablespoon). You can always add more at the table for the grown-ups.
Does mayo on the outside really make it crispier than butter?
It does, and it browns fast. Use a thin layer and keep the heat at medium-low so it turns golden instead of going from pale to scorched in 30 seconds.