Common Questions
What is the “holy trinity” in gumbo?
Onion, celery, and bell pepper. It is the flavor base that shows up in a lot of Louisiana cooking, kind of like a Cajun and Creole version of mirepoix.
How dark should my roux be?
For this gumbo, aim for deep peanut butter to milk chocolate. Lighter roux thickens more, darker roux tastes deeper. If you are new to roux, stop at peanut butter color the first time and call it a win.
My roux smells burnt. Can I save it?
If it smells like burnt popcorn or looks speckled black, it is done. Sadly, you cannot un-burn a roux. Dump it, wipe the pot, and start over. The good news is your second roux always goes faster because you are less nervous.
Okra or filé powder, or both?
You can use either. Okra thickens while it simmers and adds a classic flavor. Filé (ground sassafras) is usually stirred in off heat at the end. Using both is fine, but go easy on filé or it can get a little gummy. Also, do not boil the gumbo after adding filé.
Can I make gumbo without andouille?
Yes. Use smoked sausage, kielbasa, or even diced smoked turkey. You want something smoky and salty to carry the pot.
Fresh or frozen okra?
Both work. Frozen sliced okra is convenient and goes straight into the pot. Fresh okra is great too, just slice it and add it the same way. Either one will help thicken the gumbo as it simmers.
Where do I find filé powder?
Look in the spice aisle, sometimes near Cajun seasonings, or grab it online. A little goes a long way, and it lasts a while in the pantry.
Should gumbo be spicy?
It can be. I keep the base gently warm, then let everyone add hot sauce at the table. That way the kids and heat-lovers can both win.
